Brother TN-2450 vs TN-2350 — What's the Difference? 🖨️
Here's one of the most common mix-ups in the Brother toner world: the TN-2350 and TN-2450 look almost identical. Same black box, similar part number, nearly the same price. But fitting the wrong one is a classic mistake — and one that's easy to avoid once you know what to look for.
Ollie and Noodle have sniffed out all the details so you don't have to. 🐾
TL;DR
- TN-2350 → older Brother laser printers (pre-2017 era)
- TN-2450 → newer Brother laser printers (2017 onward)
- They are not interchangeable
- Both have quality compatible options available for under $15
What's Actually Different?
Despite looking nearly the same, the TN-2350 and TN-2450 serve different generations of Brother printers. The chip and cartridge recognition differ, so if you fit the wrong one, your printer will likely display an error or refuse to print.
Page Yield
Both cartridges have the same rated yield:
- Standard yield: ~1,200 pages (5% coverage)
So yield isn't the distinguishing factor — it's purely about printer compatibility.
Price (Genuine vs Compatible)
| Cartridge | Genuine RRP | FetchInk Compatible | |-----------|-------------|---------------------| | TN-2350 | ~$146 | $12.40 | | TN-2450 | ~$147 | $13.91 |
The compatible savings are substantial — over 90% off genuine pricing.
Which Printers Use TN-2350?
The TN-2350 suits the older generation of Brother mono laser printers:
- HL-L2300D
- HL-L2340DW
- HL-L2365DW
- HL-L2380DW
- MFC-L2700DW
- MFC-L2703DW
- MFC-L2740DW
- DCP-L2500D
- DCP-L2520DW
- DCP-L2540DN
If your Brother printer model ends in a number below L2700, there's a good chance it uses the TN-2350.
Which Printers Use TN-2450?
The TN-2450 suits the newer generation:
- HL-L2350DW
- HL-L2375DW
- HL-L2395DW
- MFC-L2710DW
- MFC-L2713DW
- MFC-L2730DW
- MFC-L2750DW (one of Australia's best-selling home office printers)
- DCP-L2510D
- DCP-L2530DW
- DCP-L2550DN
If you bought your Brother printer in 2017 or later, it almost certainly uses the TN-2450.
How to Check Your Printer Model
Not sure which generation you have? Here's the fastest way to check:
- Look at the label on the printer — the model number is printed on a sticker, usually on the front or underneath.
- Check the current toner box — it will say TN-2350 or TN-2450 clearly on the packaging.
- Print a configuration page — on most Brother printers, hold the Go button for 4 seconds.
You can also search your model on our site and we'll show you the right cartridge.
The Compatible Toner Angle 🐾
Here's where Ollie and Noodle really sit up and pay attention: the price difference between genuine and compatible toner is enormous.
Genuine TN-2450: ~$147 per cartridge Compatible TN-2450 from FetchInk: $13.91
If your office prints 500 pages a month, you're going through roughly 5 cartridges per year. That's:
- Genuine: ~$735/year
- Compatible: ~$70/year
- Annual saving: ~$665
And before anyone asks — yes, compatible toner is legal and safe. Under Australian Consumer Law (backed by the ACCC), using compatible cartridges cannot void your printer warranty. Brother cannot require you to use their branded consumables to maintain warranty coverage.
Which Should You Buy?
Simple:
- Check your printer model number (label on the printer or config page)
- Match it to the list above — TN-2350 or TN-2450
- Buy compatible and save 90%
Shop TN-2350 compatible → Shop TN-2450 compatible →
Or grab a 3-pack of TN-2450 compatible for even better value — $41.11 for three cartridges, which works out to $13.70 each.
Ollie & Noodle's Verdict 🐾
Don't let the similar part numbers trip you up. TN-2350 and TN-2450 are different cartridges for different printer generations — check your model number first, then buy the right one.
And when you do, go compatible. The quality is there, the savings are real, and your printer warranty is protected under Australian law.
Quick reference:
- ✅ TN-2350 → older Brother printers (pre-2017)
- ✅ TN-2450 → newer Brother printers (2017 onward)
- ✅ Not interchangeable — always check your model
- ✅ Compatible versions save 90%+ vs genuine
- ✅ Compatible toner cannot void your warranty (ACCC)