Brother vs HP vs Canon: Which Printer Brand Offers the Cheapest Toner? 💰

When it comes to buying a printer in Australia, the sticker price is just the beginning. The real cost is the toner you'll be feeding it for years to come — and that's where the three big brands diverge significantly.

Ollie and Noodle have put their noses to work, comparing real toner prices across Brother, HP, and Canon to answer the question every budget-conscious Aussie wants answered: which brand gives you the cheapest toner? 🐾

The Contenders

Let's compare apples to apples (or kibble to kibble 🐕). We'll look at the most popular home-office and small-business models from each brand, using both genuine and compatible toner prices from FetchInk — all prices in AUD and inclusive of GST.

Brother — The Budget Champion 🏆

Brother has built a strong reputation in Australia for affordable, reliable printers with some of the cheapest toner on the market.

Popular Models & Toner Costs:

| Printer | Toner Model | Yield | Genuine Price | Compatible Price | Cost Per Page | |---------|-------------|-------|--------------|-----------------|---------------| | HL-L2350DW | TN-2450 | 3,000 pages | ~$89 | ~$25 | 0.8c | | MFC-L2713DW | TN-2450 | 3,000 pages | ~$89 | ~$25 | 0.8c | | HL-L3230CDW | TN-257 set (CMYK) | 2,300–3,000 pages | ~$350 | ~$89 | ~3.0c (colour) | | MFC-L8900CDW | TN-443 set (CMYK) | 8,000 pages (BK) | ~$520 | ~$110 | ~1.8c (colour) |

Brother's sweet spot: The TN-2450 is one of the most affordable toner cartridges in Australia. At ~$25 for a compatible cartridge yielding 3,000 pages, it's incredibly hard to beat. Brother mono lasers consistently deliver the lowest cost per page of any brand.

HP — The Premium Player 💎

HP is the most recognisable printer brand globally, and their LaserJet range is popular in Australian offices. But that brand recognition comes at a premium when it's time to buy toner.

Popular Models & Toner Costs:

| Printer | Toner Model | Yield | Genuine Price | Compatible Price | Cost Per Page | |---------|-------------|-------|--------------|-----------------|---------------| | LaserJet Pro M404dn | CF258X | 10,000 pages | ~$349 | ~$55 | 0.6c | | LaserJet Pro M404dn | CF258A | 3,000 pages | ~$189 | ~$35 | 1.2c | | Color LaserJet Pro M454dn | W2040X set (CMYK) | 6,000–7,500 pages | ~$900 | ~$160 | ~2.7c (colour) | | LaserJet Pro MFP 4101fdw | W1510X | 5,000 pages | ~$249 | ~$50 | 1.0c |

HP's catch: HP genuine toner is among the most expensive on the market. The CF258X at $349 for a genuine cartridge is eye-watering. However, HP's high-yield cartridges offer excellent page yields, which means compatible HP toner can actually be very competitive on a cost-per-page basis. The CF258X compatible at ~$55 for 10,000 pages is just 0.6c per page — actually beating Brother on per-page cost for high-volume printing.

HP's other catch: HP has introduced "dynamic security" on some newer printer models, which can block compatible cartridges through firmware updates. Always check compatibility before buying, and consider disabling automatic firmware updates. At FetchInk, we clearly mark which cartridges work with which HP models and firmware versions.

Canon — The Middle Ground ⚖️

Canon sits between Brother's budget-friendliness and HP's premium positioning. Their imageCLASS range offers solid printers with reasonable toner costs.

Popular Models & Toner Costs:

| Printer | Toner Model | Yield | Genuine Price | Compatible Price | Cost Per Page | |---------|-------------|-------|--------------|-----------------|---------------| | imageCLASS LBP223dw | CART-057H | 10,000 pages | ~$289 | ~$49 | 0.5c | | imageCLASS MF445dw | CART-057H | 10,000 pages | ~$289 | ~$49 | 0.5c | | imageCLASS MF746Cx | CART-055H set (CMYK) | 5,900–7,600 pages | ~$580 | ~$120 | ~2.4c (colour) | | imageCLASS LBP664Cx | CART-055H set (CMYK) | 5,900–7,600 pages | ~$580 | ~$120 | ~2.4c (colour) |

Canon's strength: The CART-057H is a hidden gem. With 10,000 pages yield and a compatible price of ~$49, Canon delivers the lowest mono cost per page in this comparison at just 0.5c. Canon also tends to be less aggressive than HP when it comes to blocking compatible cartridges, making them a reliable choice.

The Verdict: Cost Per Page Comparison

Let's put the numbers side by side for the most popular models:

Mono (Black & White) Printing

| Brand | Model | Compatible Toner | Yield | Cost Per Page | |-------|-------|-----------------|-------|---------------| | Canon | LBP223dw / MF445dw | CART-057H (~$49) | 10,000 | 0.5c ⭐ | | HP | LaserJet M404dn | CF258X (~$55) | 10,000 | 0.6c | | Brother | HL-L2350DW | TN-2450 (~$25) | 3,000 | 0.8c |

Colour Printing

| Brand | Model | Compatible Set | Yield (BK) | Cost Per Page (approx) | |-------|-------|---------------|------------|----------------------| | Brother | MFC-L8900CDW | TN-443 set (~$110) | 8,000 | ~1.8c ⭐ | | Canon | MF746Cx | CART-055H set (~$120) | 7,600 | ~2.4c | | HP | M454dn | W2040X set (~$160) | 7,500 | ~2.7c |

So, Who Wins?

It depends on how you look at it:

🏆 Cheapest Toner Cartridge (Lowest Outlay)

Winner: Brother. The TN-2450 compatible at ~$25 is the cheapest cartridge to buy. If upfront cost is your main concern and you print moderate volumes, Brother is your brand.

🏆 Cheapest Cost Per Page — Mono

Winner: Canon. The CART-057H compatible at 0.5c per page edges out the competition for high-volume mono printing. HP's CF258X is close behind at 0.6c.

🏆 Cheapest Cost Per Page — Colour

Winner: Brother. The TN-443 series in the MFC-L8900CDW delivers the lowest colour cost per page at ~1.8c with compatible cartridges.

🏆 Best Overall Value

Winner: Brother. While Canon and HP can beat Brother on per-page cost in specific high-yield scenarios, Brother offers the best combination of affordable printers, cheap toner, wide model range, and hassle-free compatible cartridge support. There's a reason Brother is the most popular printer brand in Australian small offices.

Important Considerations for Australian Buyers

GST-Inclusive Pricing

All prices listed above include GST. When comparing prices across retailers, always confirm you're looking at GST-inclusive figures. Some online sellers (especially international ones) show ex-GST pricing, which can be misleading.

Australian Consumer Law Protection

Under the Australian Consumer Law (administered by the ACCC), consumers have strong protections:

• Using compatible cartridges does not void your printer warranty — manufacturers cannot refuse warranty service simply because you used a third-party consumable
• Products must be of acceptable quality and fit for purpose
• You're entitled to a repair, replacement, or refund if products are faulty

At FetchInk, all our compatible cartridges come with a quality guarantee. If something isn't right, we'll make it right — no chasing your tail required. 🐾

Firmware Updates and Compatibility

HP is known for releasing firmware updates that can block compatible cartridges. Canon and Brother are generally more compatible-friendly. If you're buying an HP printer with the intention of using compatible toner, consider:

• Disabling automatic firmware updates
• Checking our product listings for firmware compatibility notes
• Contacting our team if you're unsure

The Bottom Line

For most Australian homes and offices, Brother offers the best overall toner value — cheap printers, cheap compatible cartridges, and no compatibility headaches. Canon is the dark horse for high-volume mono printing with exceptional cost-per-page ratios. HP delivers solid performance but comes at a premium, especially for genuine cartridges.

No matter which brand you're running, switching to compatible cartridges from FetchInk saves you 50–80% compared to genuine — that's the biggest single saving you can make, regardless of brand.

Ollie and Noodle reckon the best printer is the one that doesn't cost you a fortune to feed. Sound familiar? 🦴

---

Find the cheapest compatible toner for your printer at FetchInk. Use our Printer Finder to see your options, or get in touch if you need help choosing.